May 22, 2020 relevant cross examination and other questions may be asked of a party or witness. This perspective seeks to enhance legal studies by examining and interpreting legal texts using the techniques of literary critics. Good cross examination is an instrument for communicating to the judge or jury with candour, clarity and concision. On cross examination, however, lee acknowledged several entries from his facebook page where he reported frequently working out and also playing sports such as basketball, tennis, ultimate frisbee, and softball, sometimes engaging in multiple sessions of. Direct examination is more important than cross examination, the opening statement or closing argument. Cross examination is where you get to question the other sides witness. The prosecutors crossexamination can be an effective. Preparing an effective cross examination of the over. Sep 21, 2005 heres a selfexplanatory quote from boudwin v.
The examination of a witness, by the party who calls him, shall be called his examination inchief. Cambridge studies in american literature and culture 21. The scope of cross examination is intentionally broad. While no substitute exists for experience i have tried to outline some practical guidelines to assist those who are developing their own style and techniques. On crossexamination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. Most attorneys have the skills for a basic cross, but need an additional framework for cross examination of expert witnesses at both deposition and trial. Make a list of the statements of fact or opinion that you intend to challenge on cross examination. The child care law reporting project grants permission for the reproduction of quotations from this text, provided due acknowledgment of the source is made and provided such citations do not exceed 400 words in length.
More than any other litigation skill, the ability to take great adverse depositions determines case outcome. Crossexamination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. Think about how you can force an admission if necessary. Stages in examination of witness section 7 there are three stages of examination of witness, examination inchief, cross examination and re examination. Cross examination, like any other element of litigation, does not exist in a vacuum. The decisive difference in my view is that if the adverse witness bites you, the jurors are more likely to think it is your own fault than if a witness called by the other side does so. Project gutenbergs the art of crossexamination, by francis l. In deposition, cross examine the witness to summarize and lock in her testimony before trial. It has been accepted for inclusion in journal of criminal law and criminology by an authorized editor of northwestern university school of law scholarly. Associate professor of law, mcgeorge school of law, university of the pacific, sacramento, california. Sep 04, 2016 the gap between direct and cross examination, for the adverse witness is called in your case but is treated as if on cross examination. The rules about cross examination arent as strict as they are for direct examination when you question your own witnesses. He will in this way avoid many of the erroneous rulings on questions.
Law and literature movement turns to the use of literary criticism to examine legal texts. Crossexamining the expert witness with the aid of books core. Investment adviser principal and agency cross trading. Crossexamination legal definition of crossexamination. The ultimate challenge for a trial lawyer is to extract information from the opponents witnesses to support their clients case andor undermine the credibility of the opponents position. Cooper, hawthorne, stowe, and melville as you such as. The lens reflects both ways, and we learn as much about the literature in the context of contemporary legal concerns. You should not attempt to conduct either a direct or cross examination of an expert without first referring to chapters 6 and 7 on the examination of lay witnesses. There are two basic purposes of cross examinations. A crossexamination of gender, race, and empire in victorian law and literature harvard womens law journal, vol. More cross examinations are suicidal than homicidal. Crossexamination national district attorneys association.
Cross examination serves to discredit direct testimony, to discredit the witness, and to reflect on the credibility of other witnesses. Pdf striking a balance between the rights of defendants and. Cambridge core american studies cross examinations of law and literature. Crossexamination definition is the examination of a witness who has already testified in order to check or discredit the witnesss testimony, knowledge, or credibility. It will agreed ease you to see guide cross examinations of law and literature. Cast doubt on unfavourable evidence given by the witness. This article outlines ten tips for both direct and cross examination, which certainly is not an exhaustive list. The purpose of cross examination is not simply to attack an adversary, but to strengthen your own case. Danforth, but cannot hold up to the scrutiny of abigail and the other girls. Interestingly, mary warren withstands the harsh crossexamination of. Every party has a right to cross examine a witness produced by his antagonist, in order to test whether the witness has the knowledge of the things he. Note title ix regulations, title ix text for text proposed to. The purpose of crossexamination is to ascertain the credibility of a witness before the factfinder and to bring out contradictions and improbabilities in hisher earlier testimony, by putting leading questions thus by trapping the witness into admissions that.
Nonclass learning law unplugged the 10 commandments of cross examination having seen irving youngers lecture at uc hastings college of law in san francisco, on the 10 commandments of cross examination which in reality are fewer, but repeated in different ways, i will proceed to analyze the three that most caught my. An examination of lengthy, contested and complex child. Mcgeorge school of law scholarly articles mcgeorge school of law faculty scholarship 1987 the child witness. Best books on cross examination pdf the first rule of cross examination is that ther. Buckner despite the wisdom of this old saying, some lawyers fail to follow the rules of cross examination. Perhaps we can explore the issue further by opening up this textbook and reading from it. The method of eliciting truth by the method of cross examination is as old as human nature. Direct and crossexamination law offices of steven c. Edical bout the liability and catastrophic personal injury and transportation law.
In cross examinations of law and literature brook thomas uses legal thought and legal practice as a lens through which to read some of the important fictions of antebellum america. On direct examination, witnesses are controlled through preparation and rehearsal. Popularly feted, cross examination was immortalised in john henry wigmores 18631943 famous dictum that it is the greatest legal engine ever invented for the discovery of truth. Make a list of the positive statements that you expect the witness to admit during cross examination. There is a new chapter on cross examination to the fallacies of testimony, which is intended to be a brief discussion of the philosophy of oral. Sir points out that one should always be careful as to what question to ask and not ask while cross examination, as even one single wrong step can result in the whole case of accused. The questioning of a witness or party during a trial, hearing, or deposition by the party opposing the one who asked the person to testify in order to evaluate the truth of that persons testimony, to develop the testimony further, or to accomplish any other objective. In order to do this, you have to organize your cross examination. Child care law reporting project report of a research study commissioned by the department of children and youth affairs an examination of lengthy, contested and complex child protection cases in the district court by carol coulter march 2018. Tv lawyers such as perry mason and ben matlock conduct impromptu cross examinations with such mastery that the witness or even a spectator in the gallery confesses to the crime on the spot. Techniques for direct examination, cross examination, and. The six sections that follow illustrate this process of cross examination, emphasizing the importance of closely examining a research basis, b unclear terms and deductive fallacies, c inferential errors and confirmation. Different literary texts have legal language, court scenes, cross examinations, lawyers, witnesses, judge, and audience.
Before a complainant, respondent, or witness answers a cross examination or other question, the decisionmakers must first determine whether the question is relevant and explain any decision to exclude a question as not relevant, thus implying that a school. Crossexamination by the defense asks the jury to question what was done procedurally during the stop and arrest, to challenge the validity of scientific tests or to doubt the law enforcement officers competency or even integrity. The crossexamination of mayella ewell university of alabama. Cross examination is the questioning of a witness at a trial or hearing by the opposing party who called the witness to testify. Introduction many lawyers spend a considerable amount of their trial preparation thinking about voir. To elicit evidence from the witness which is favourable to or supports your case evidence which supports your version of the facts in issue. The project gutenberg ebook of the art of crossexamination, by. Witness crossexaminations in nonstranger assault crimes language and law linguagem e direito, vol. Small june 29, 2017 our next series of columns will address the subject of cross examination. But her denial is final and may not be contradicted any further. Re examination is defined as the examination of a witness, subsequent to the cross examination by the party who called him, shall be called his re examination.
Cooper, hawthorne, stowe, and melville and numerous ebook collections from. The art of cross examination with the cross examinations of important witnesses in some celebrated cases by francis wellman of the new york bar presented by the law offices of eric michael papp, corona, california. Foundations of effective crossexamination the litigator. Oct 25, 2007 crossexaminations of law and literature by brook thomas, 9780521409704, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Witness crossexaminations in nonstranger assault crimes. The author expresses appreciation to professor linda carter for her comments on drafts of this article.
Introduction cross examination is a weapon, an effective weapon if handled correctly and a dangerous. You have to think about the points that you want to make on cross examination and then break them down into a multitude of little points. We come up with the money for cross examinations of law and literature. The lens reflects both ways, and we learn as much about the literature in the context of contemporary legal concerns as we do about the legal ideologies that the. This course will explore the intersection between law and literature. Literature, area studies, american literature, sociolegal. Good cross examination proceeds from more modest and realistic expectations. The art of cross examination law offices of eric michael papp. The literature on the subject is filled with accounts of epic cross examinations by legendary lawyers, disastrous. A physical confrontation with witnesses may be denied only where this is necessary to further an important public policy, and the. The best way to learn it has been said to be real life experience because there is no substitute for the same. Break cross examination into a series of logical progressions to each specific goal.
Rule 611b allows cross examination on any matter relevant to any issue in the case, including credibility. Cambridge core american studies crossexaminations of law and literature. The cross examination of adverse deponents fact and expert is a subject that deserves a full semesters course of study. Cross examination law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Like the plot it discloses, the deposition collapses history, law, and literature. Cross examination takes place immediately after direct examination, and is conducted from behind counsel table, or from the podium.
Eddie craig will soon be launching a brand new site geared toward publicizing and organizing the efforts of the patriot community groups and organizations. University of houston law center a nationally ranked texas. Literatures influence on the law and legal actors university of. Cross examination is commonly esteemed the severest test of an advocates skill and perhaps it demands beyond any other of his duties the exercise of ingenuity. The purpose of crossexamination is to ascertain the credibility of a witness before the factfinder and to bring out contradictions and improbabilities in hisher earlier testimony, by putting leading questions. In law, cross examination is the interrogation of a witness called by ones opponent. Crossexamination definition of crossexamination by. Masculinity in american law and literature 239 saul. Witness control try enough cases, and youll run across all variations of cross examinees, from the soft. Search across a wide variety of disciplines and sources.
Dan small recently returned from his second trip to uzbekistan, talking with judges and lawyers there about the adversarial system. He is a vice chair of the medical in this issue this article is intended to serve as a primer for the defense attorneys use in defending pain management physicians against allegations of overprescribing opioid pain medications to patients and also to provide the tools necessary for effective cross. Ten tips for direct examination and crossexamination. When an objection is made that a question exceeds the permissible scope of cross 1 see e. An examination of lengthy, contested and complex child protection cases in the district court. A crossexamination of gender, race, and empire in victorian law and literature. Organizing your cross examination the chapter method mastering this method of cross examination requires discipline and practice. In summary examination and cross examination of a witness involves some of the most temperamental abilities of the counsel and hence re privy to a very few as to what is the art of cross examination. Crossexamination causes captain queeg to reveal his mental instability in the caine mutiny. The prosecutrix may be cross examined as to acts of immorality with men, other than the accused, for purpose of impeaching her credit in such a case. Examination, crossexamination, and redirect examination. Nonclass learning law unplugged the 10 commandments of cross examination having seen irving youngers lecture at uc hastings college of law in san francisco, on the 10 commandments of cross examination which in reality are fewer, but repeated in different ways, i will proceed to analyze the three that most caught my attention. Google scholar provides a simple way to broadly search for scholarly literature.
1318 369 1374 1221 1278 1389 303 206 1292 472 139 626 735 844 1284 783 1735 966 653 897 693 1403 648 66 271 1214 1418 158 1234 212 93 698 206 1606 1084 1147 102 812